Wednesday, November 2, 2011

MTA webcast series summary: Intermarket Relationships

Below is an email summary I prepared of the latest MTA webcast presentation by John Murphy from October 19 2011.
__________________________________________________________________

Hey all. Today I attended a webcast presentation by John Murphy (of stockcharts.com & MTA). John has been around a long time and is famous for his intermarket relationships analysis (one of which is required reading for the CMT). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Murphy_(economist)

If you are at all interested in the macro environment or economics and how it ties to the stock market, then his intermarkets book, may be for you. It is great at tying together the financial markets, business cycle, and technical analysis all together.
http://www.amazon.com/Intermarket-Analysis-Profiting-Relationships-Trading/dp/0471023299/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1319048257&sr=8-1

I have attached the slides, which are pretty self explanatory and an easy flip through to see what's going on with a lot of different markets (contact me to obtain). You likely have already recognized some of them, but it helps to put correlations in easy to read charts. Below is a short summary of the slides in pretty much order with the presentation...

Intro: "You have to go back to the 30's to find similar correlations as today". Most "traditional" relationships have broken down in the last decade (starting with the Asian Crisis). The reason behind this is the deflationary theme we are currently in compared to the primarily inflationary period of the past. He cites 3 major deflationary events recently, the Japanese bubble bursting (1989), the asian contagion, and the US property bubble burst.

Slides 4&5: There was a paradigm shift around the time of the Asian Crisis. Bond yields and stocks started to move together. He cites a deflationary environment as the primary reason. He doesn't expect this relationship to revert back to the "norm" until deflation is out of the picture. Slide 5 shows that same relationship in 2011. In august 2011, bond yields didn't confirm the rally, which gave a hint stocks would see new lows.

Slides 6&7: Stocks and Commodities are positively correlated (extremely). This has not occurred since the 1930s. There is no other real good example in history and is one of the reasons he sees us in a deflationary environment. Commodities, like yields, seem to be leading stocks. He comments simply that Bernanke wouldn't talk about it so much if it wasn't a concern and prevalent.
One of the most reliable inverse relationships is the dollar/commodities; Recently a similar relationship has occurred between the dollar and stocks.

Slides 11&12; Stocks peak when energy outperforms...This occurred through the summer 2011. Rotation into safety, also has occurred...too early to tell if rotation into safety is over and downturn is "complete", but that cycle is longer term. Stocks are in red on slide 11 and the business cycle is in green.

Slides 14+; US stocks outperform foreign stocks when the dollar rises; however, they both fall. The Euro is something like 56% of the US Dollar Index and the majority of the 5 components.

Euro stocks are leading the US stocks right now

Ratio charts are a great way to see what is really happening and driving prices (I agree).

Q&A session...
-A China revaluation would result in inflation in America & decline of the dollar

-Use the 10 year bond when comparing across countries because most others don't have 30 year bonds.

-Expects "deflationary environment to continue until proven otherwise". Will look at bond/stock relationship to help tell.

Take care everyone and good luck! Let me know if you have any questions.
Chad

No comments:

Post a Comment